Response 82437088

Back to Response listing

Personal information

3. Do your views officially represent those of an organisation?

Please select all that apply
(Required)
Checkbox: Unticked Yes, I am authorised to submit feedback on behalf of an organisation
Checkbox: Ticked No, these are my personal views

Consent to publish submission

4. Do you give permission for your response to be published?

Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Ticked Yes - I give permission for my response/submission to be published.
Radio button: Unticked No - I would like my response/submission to remain confidential but understand that de-identified aggregate data may be published.
Radio button: Unticked I am a CASA officer.

About you

5. What best describes your primary role? Select all that apply

Please select all that apply
Checkbox: Unticked Air transport pilot
Checkbox: Unticked Chief pilot
Checkbox: Unticked Commercial pilot
Checkbox: Unticked Recreational pilot/private pilot
Checkbox: Unticked Remotely piloted aircraft systems Pilot
Checkbox: Unticked Student pilot
Checkbox: Unticked Safety manager
Checkbox: Ticked Other
Other please specify
Sports Aviation: Paraglider Pilot

6. Which sector are you primarily in? Select all that apply

Please select all that apply
Checkbox: Unticked Aerial work
Checkbox: Unticked Aerodrome services
Checkbox: Unticked Air traffic controller
Checkbox: Unticked Air transport operator – large (Part 121)
Checkbox: Unticked Air transport operator – small (Part 135/charter)
Checkbox: Unticked Business aviation
Checkbox: Unticked Flight training
Checkbox: Unticked Private flying
Checkbox: Ticked Sport aviation
Checkbox: Unticked Remotely piloted aircraft systems
Checkbox: Unticked Government organisation
Checkbox: Unticked Consultant and other professional services/unions
Checkbox: Unticked Other

7. What flight rules do you operate under?

Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked IFR only
Radio button: Ticked VFR only
Radio button: Unticked Both IFR and VFR
Radio button: Unticked Not applicable

8. Do you conduct operations with a sport aviation body? Select all that apply

Please select all that apply
(Required)
Checkbox: Unticked No, I do not conduct operations with a sport aviation body
Checkbox: Unticked Australian Balloon Federation
Checkbox: Unticked Australian Parachute Federation
Checkbox: Unticked Australian Skydiving Association
Checkbox: Unticked Australian Sport Rotorcraft Association
Checkbox: Unticked Australian Warbirds Association Limited
Checkbox: Unticked Gliding Federation Australia
Checkbox: Unticked Recreational Aviation Australia
Checkbox: Ticked Sports Aviation Federation of Australia
Checkbox: Unticked Other (please specify)

9. What type of aircraft do you operate? Select all that apply

Please select all that apply
(Required)
Checkbox: Unticked Helicopter
Checkbox: Unticked Aeroplane
Checkbox: Unticked Gyroplane
Checkbox: Unticked Hot air balloon
Checkbox: Unticked Air ship
Checkbox: Unticked Powered-lift aircraft
Checkbox: Ticked Not applicable

ADS-B ground station

10. Do you agree there is a need to install an Automatic Dependent Surveillance - Broadcast (ADS-B) ground station in the vicinity of Ballina to improve surveillance?

Level of agreement
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Ticked Agree
Radio button: Unticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
If an ADS-D ground station is installed, SAFA aircraft (paragliders/hang gliders) will be observable if they are fitted with a portable self-contained ADS-B electronic conspicuity (EC) device. This would decrease the risk of airspace conflict. The installation of an ADS-B ground station would assist in increasing the coverage of this service. Increasingly, instruments used by sport aviation pilots and applications running on mobile devices are able to display aircraft position data from multiple sources, including ADS-B transmissions. With the increased presence of ADS-B EC devices, increased and enhanced alerted see-and-avoid capability is available.

A comprehensive financial assistance scheme to assist all airspace users to purchase ADS-B EC devices would greatly enhance situational awareness for all pilots. The currently proposed rebate eliminates the majority of our pilots from access to this scheme and represents a lost opportunity for safety in aviation.

11. When do you think an ADS-B ground station is required in the vicinity of Ballina?

When is ADS-B ground station needed?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Ticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Unticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Approach control service

12. Do you agree there is a need to provide an Approach Control Service to IFR aircraft operating into Ballina Byron Gateway Airport?

Level of agreement - Approach Control Service
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Unticked Agree
Radio button: Ticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
Not applicable to our operations.

13. When do you think an Approach Control Service for IFR into Ballina is required?

When is Approach Control Service required?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Separation service

14. Do you agree there is a need to provide a separation service between IFR aircraft operating into Ballina Byron Gateway Airport?

Is separation service needed?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Unticked Agree
Radio button: Ticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
Not applicable to our operations.

15. When do you think a separation service between IFR aircraft operating into Ballina is required?

When is separation service needed?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Sequencing aircraft

16. Do you agree there is a need to sequence all aircraft to and from the runway and within the circuit area to proactively manage runway usage at Ballina Byron Gateway Airport?

Level of agreement - sequencing
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Unticked Agree
Radio button: Ticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree

17. When do you think a sequencing service is required?

When is sequencing service needed?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Traffic information

18. Do you agree there is a need to provide traffic information on known VFR traffic to all aircraft operating into Ballina Byron Gateway Airport?

Level of agreement - traffic information
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Ticked Agree
Radio button: Unticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
Where that information is available (e.g. ADS-B EC device data), it would improve situational awareness for all airspace users.

19. When do you think a traffic information service should be available?

When is traffic information service needed?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Controlled airspace

20. If controlled airspace was established, do you agree there is a need for all VFR aircraft operating into Ballina Byron Gateway Airport to be known to ATC?

If controlled airspace was established, do you agree there is a need for all VFR aircraft operating into Ballina Byron Gateway Airport to be known to ATC?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Ticked Agree
Radio button: Unticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
Improved situational awareness. But please note that our aircraft operate within the conditions specified in CASA EX123/21.

21. When do you think a controlled airspace service should be available?

When do you think a controlled airspace service should be available?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Detecting non-cooperative aircraft and vehicles

22. Do you agree there is a need to establish a capability to detect non-cooperative aircraft and vehicles in the immediate vicinity of the runway at Ballina to enable corrective action?

Do you agree there is a need to establish a capability to detect non-cooperative aircraft and vehicles in the immediate vicinity of the runway at Ballina to enable corrective action?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Unticked Agree
Radio button: Ticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
Not applicable to our operations.

23. When do you think a non-cooperative aircraft and vehicle detection service should be available?

When do you think a non-cooperative aircraft and vehicle detection service should be available?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Aerodrome control service

24. Do you agree there is a need to provide an Aerodrome Control Service to aircraft operating into or out of Ballina Byron Gateway Airport?

Level of agreement - aerodrome control service
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Unticked Agree
Radio button: Ticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree
Please tell us why you think this:
Not applicable to our operations.

25. When do you think an Aerodrome Control Service is required?

When do you think an aerodrome control service is required?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked As soon as possible
Radio button: Unticked December 2022
Radio button: Unticked June 2023
Radio button: Unticked December 2023
Radio button: Unticked June 2024
Radio button: Unticked December 2024
Radio button: Unticked 2025 or later
Radio button: Ticked Not sure
Radio button: Unticked NA - I don't think it is needed

Increasing situational awareness

26. Do you agree that uncertified aerodromes and flight training areas around Ballina should be promulgated in aeronautical publications to increase pilot situational awareness?

Do you agree that uncertified aerodromes and flight training areas around Ballina should be promulgated in aeronautical publications to increase pilot situational awareness?
Please select one item
(Required)
Radio button: Unticked Strongly agree
Radio button: Unticked Agree
Radio button: Ticked Neutral
Radio button: Unticked Disagree
Radio button: Unticked Strongly disagree

Final comments

27. Do you have any other feedback or concerns regarding the Draft Airspace Review of Ballina 2022?

Do you have any other feedback or concerns regarding the Draft Airspace Review of Ballina 2022?
Currently, SAFA aircraft operate within the YBNA MBA using two methods:

1. SAFA aircraft operate at Lennox Head and Numulgi, not above 400ft AGL IAW CASA EX123/21, or

2. For transit and within the BA, as well as, within the YLIS/YCAS/YEVD CTAF areas, using standard non-controlled airspace broadcast procedures.

Members of SAFA and NRHGPG Club request that the status quo of operational procedures and restrictions be retained for any increase in airspace classification for the YBNA MBA. This may involve an exemption to CAO 95.8 (sub-regulation 10.4) for transit operations.

Members of SAFA have demonstrated complete compliance with CASA EX123/21, as well as the standard non-controlled broadcast requirements within MBA and CTAF areas.

To my knowledge, there have been no recorded incidents of traffic conflict between SAFA aircraft and other IFR/VFR aircraft within the YBNA MBA.

Currently, there are no RPT arrivals) departures from/to the north of YBNA. Due to this, and the operational restriction on the club/members transiting the proposed Class D airspace to the north of YBNA, the Club/members propose that the Class D airspace be amended to be south of a direct line from BBAY to YLIS.

This approximately follows the line of the Lismore Bangalow Rd and would serve as a reliable landmark in order to allow VFR pilots to avoid the proposed Class D airspace. This would also allow members of NRHGPG Club to transit to the west from the club sites north of Bangalow outside of the proposed Class D airspace. An added benefit would be that RAAus pilots could also transit from YTYH to YLIS/YCAS OCTA.

This proposed modification would not increase the likelihood risk of a traffic conflict between RPT aircraft and NRHGPG Club aircraft.