Proposed relocation of NVIS legislation into Parts 91, 133 and 138 Manuals of Standards - (CD 2109OS)

Closed 29 Oct 2021

Opened 1 Oct 2021

Feedback updated 22 Nov 2021

We asked

This consultation asked industry to review the proposed transition of the night vision imaging system (NVIS) legislation from Civil Aviation Order (CAO) 82.6 into the relevant Parts of the MOS. The consultation has now closed, and a summary of the feedback is provided below.

About this consultation

Prior to the consultation, two NVIS Technical Working Group (TWG) meetings were held to develop the draft MOS instrument, after which the developed draft instrument was subject to this public consultation. Approximately 14 NVIS operators participated in the TWG and were advised of the consultation document and the opportunity to provide further comment. Also, CASA's Flight Standards Branch held an online meeting for the remaining five NVIS Operators who were not part of the NVIS TWG, and they were briefed on the content of the consultation document.

You said

In total, CASA received feedback from two separate NVIS operators relating to the transition of the NVIS legislation.

The first operator's comment related to minor inconsistencies between the NVIS flight rules in the different MOS parts (Part 91, Part 133 and Part 138 of CASR) and an inconsistency with an element of the VMC criteria that had changed from CAO 82.6.

The second operator's comment related to concern over the commencement date of the new flight operations rules and the short period between the NVIS legislation transition and the commencement date of 2 December 2021 for the new legislation.

Summary of feedback

No feedback was received that did not support the transition of the NVIS legislation from the CAO into the CASR. The first comment related specifically to an error in the transition of the VMC criteria from CAO 82.6 that placed conditions on the use of operating in Class C airspace, clear of cloud and inconsistency with the alternate lighting criteria contained within the Part 138 MOS. The second operator comment related to concern over the implementation timeline.

VMC criteria - Ability to operate clear of cloud Class C airspace.

The comment from the operator related to the transitional legislation that was not consistent with CAO 82.6. The VMC criteria allowing a NVIS operation to be conducted clear of cloud in Class C airspace, had conditions imposed that were not required under CAO 82.6. CASA accepted the conditions had, in effect, changed the current NVIS policy relating to the use of the VMC criteria and has removed the conditions for the final legislation.

NVIS alternate lighting

The NVIS operator also identified the wording relating to NVIS alternate lighting in Part 138 MOS, chapter 12.06, differed from the wording in Part 91 MOS, chapter 3.07 and Part 133 MOS, chapter 8.07.

CASA noted this difference was unintended and has amended the final legislation to maintain consistency of wording.

NVIS MOS transition timeline

The second operator raised a concern relating to the limited time available from the intended publication of the amended MOS's containing the NVIS legislation, and the commencement date of the legislation on 2 December 2021.

As a result of the comment, CASA contacted the operator directly to discuss the concern of the proposed transition timeline. The operator's concern related to the volume of flight rules that are due to commence on 2 December 2021, including the transition of the NVIS legislation.

CASA acknowledges there is a significant volume of flight rules due to commence on 2 December 2021. The preference was to have the NVIS flight rules embedded into the MOS at least 12 months prior to the commencement of the legislation; however, CASA has ensured all NVIS operators have been involved in the development of the transitional legislation since March 2020, including their participation in 3 NVIS TWGs. Further, CASA provided a draft of the transitional legislation in June 2021 and all members of the NVIS TWG have had access to the proposed MOS Parts. CASA has ensured the NVIS flight rules remain mostly unchanged in this transition from the CAO to the new MOS's and should not require a significant change to NVIS operators' operations manual procedures.

CASA remains committed to transitioning the NVIS legislation by 2 December 21 to ensure operators are not required to refer to the legacy NVIS legislation contained within CAO 82.6.

Additional CASA actions

CASA separately identified that the contents of a Note in the draft instrument were seemingly prescribing a safety policy regarding the situation where an NVIS crew might de-goggle during the overflight of significant cultural lighting in order to maintain aviation safety.

At the NVIS TWG meeting in November 2021 following the consultation, CASA discussed with the TWG moving the contents of the Note into the main legal provisions of the legislation. This was accepted by the TWG and these changes have been made.

We did

CASA will proceed with the transition of the NVIS legislation into the relevant MOS's to ensure NVIS operators are not required to revert to CAO 82.6 for NVIS flight rules. This transition will include the making of a separate Part 11 direction to Part 119 and Part 138 certificate holders, in accordance with the public consultation, that requires these kinds of operators to obtain CASA's approval prior to operators first using NVIS in an NVIS operation. This approval will not be required for operators already holding CAO 82.6 approvals.

Published responses

View submitted responses where consent has been given to publish the response.

Overview

CASA is seeking comment on the proposed rules for using night vision imaging systems (NVIS), that will apply from 2 December 2021.

NVIS legislation currently resides in Civil Aviation Order (CAO) 82.6 and Instrument Number 288/07 and is supported by Civil Aviation Advisory Publication 174-01. In line with the movement of flight operations related Civil Aviation Regulations and CAO’s into the Civil Aviation Safety Regulations (CASRs) and Manuals of Standards (MOSs), CASA is relocating NVIS legislation into the CASR Part 91, Part 133 and Part 138 MOS's. This transition is to be completed prior to 2 December 2021, the commencement date of the new CASR Parts. The CAO would be repealed on this date.

In the 2018 consultation of CASR Part 91, CASA proposed that the current prohibition on the use of NVIS in private operations be removed, and that NVIS be able to be used in operations other than the current limited NVIS operations permitted by CAO 82.6 for situational awareness purposes (subject to conditions). That proposal was supported but only partially enacted in Chapter 3 of the existing version of the Part 91 MOS.

The policy intent of the proposed NVIS rules is to:

  • carry across the existing rules (both operational, maintenance and NVG standards) of CAO 82.6 in a simplified and condensed manner
  • ensure the NVIS rules do not apply to a person wearing NVIS on a flight who is not a flight crew member and is not involved in air navigation or terrain avoidance functions
  • implement the full suite of safety controls appropriate to enable the use of NVIS for situational awareness purposes in private operations, aerial work operations conducted by persons who do not hold an aerial work certificate and Part 133 passenger and cargo transport operations (previously consulted)
  • move the NVIS helicopter firebombing requirements of TMI 01/2017 into the Part 138 MOS
  • move the current use of exemptions for NVIS aeroplane firebombing into a Part 138 approval (note that exemptions might still be required from Part 61 as aeroplane NVIS licensing and training rules do not yet exist in Australia)
    • CASA will continue to publish TMI 05/2019 as guidance to industry and CASA staff regarding expected standards to obtain this approval
    • CASA does not anticipate including permanent aeroplane NVIS firebombing standards into the Part 138 MOS until further operational experience is obtained during multiple fire seasons.

This consultation is also proposing that if an operator had not previously held an approval under the old CAO to conduct an NVIS flight, then beginning to use NVIS would require CASA's approval. In the short term, this is proposed to be implemented via a specific direction issued to Part 119, 138, 141 and 142 operators. At the next available regulation change opportunity, this change would be included as a mandatory significant change in paragraphs 119.020(a), 138.012(a), 141.025(a) and 142.030(a) of CASR.

An operator would only need further approval to start using NVIS during additional kinds of activities not mentioned in the initial application if, as a result of an operator’s risk assessment of these new activities, the overall level of aviation safety would decrease or be likely to decrease (see the wording of CASR paragraphs 119.020(b), 138.012(c), 141.025(c) and 142.030(c)).

Two defined terms – NVIS flight and NVIS operation – are fundamental to understanding how the proposed rules will work. A detailed explanation of these definitions can be found in the SPC document accompanying this consultation. In summary, an NVIS operation is a specialised subset of the broad term NVIS flight. Certain rules and alleviations only apply to NVIS operations and do not apply, or an alleviation is not available to, an NVIS flight that is not an NVIS operation. NVIS operations include, but are not limited to, Part 141/Part 142 training, flight testing or checking, Part 133 medical transport operations and Part 138 certificate holder operations. For example, NVIS operations are permitted to descend below the IFR and NVFR minimum heights and conduct approaches to a NVIS-HLS basic, whereas an NVIS flight that is not an NVIS operation cannot do these things.

The interrelationship between CASR Parts 91, 133 and 138 does result in some duplication across the 3 MOS's. This aspect of the regulatory structure cannot be changed at this time and would need to be the subject of future dedicated industry consultation, if such change was determined to be a priority for the industry. For this consultation, it is important that affected individuals understand when the rules contained in a particular MOS apply to a particular kind of flight. These interrelationships are explained in the ‘Key Changes’ section of the SPC document accompanying this consultation.

More Information

  • Part 91 MOS Chapter 2 (additional VMC criteria for NVIS operations)
  • Part 91 MOS Chapter 3 (operational requirements for NVIS flights that are not Part 133 operations or aerial work certificate holder flights)
  • Part 91 MOS Chapter 26 (equipment requirements for all NVIS flights except for those that are a Part 133 operation)
  • Part 133 MOS Chapter 8 (operational requirements for NVIS flights that are Part 133 operations)
  • Part 133 MOS Chapter 11 (equipment requirements for NVIS flights that are Part 133 operations)
  • Part 138 MOS Chapter 12 (operational requirements for NVIS flights that are aerial work certificate holder aerial work operations)
  • Part 138 MOS Chapter 16 (NVIS firebombing and incendiary dropping standards)
  • Part 138 MOS Chapter 17 (NVIS fire mapping standards)
  • Part 138 MOS Chapter 22 (equipment requirements specific to NVIS firebombing, incendiary dropping and fire mapping)

Impact on industry

There should be no adverse impact on industry resulting from these changes. However, there may be a need to amend some elements of existing operations manuals, subject to the policies related to existing operations manuals outlined in AC 1-03, which relate to the broader transition to the new flight operations regulations.

These changes are intended to move existing safety policies into the new CASR Part structure, whilst providing increased scope to use NVIS for situational awareness purposes as previously consulted.

Previous consultations

CASA held a Technical Working Group (TWG) on NVIS in March 2020, to focus on policy changes required prior to the transition of the NVIS legislation to the CASR's and MOS's. This TWG resulted in a significant amendment and re-issue of CAO 82.6 in October 2020. Two more NVIS TWG's were held in June and August 2021 to allow NVIS Operators to review and comment on the transitional legislation. These comments have been incorporated into the proposed rules that are the subject of this consultation.

Why your views matter

CASA recognises the valuable contribution community and industry consultations make to the policy decision-making process and future regulatory change. We are consulting to ensure that the proposed new rules are clearly articulated and will work in practice and as they are intended. Comments are sought from every sector of the community. This includes the general public, government agencies and all sectors of the aviation industry, whether as an aviator, aviation consumer and/or provider of related products and services.

This consultation seeks feedback on CD 2109OS which summarises the proposed relocation of NVIS Policy from CAO 82.6 into Parts 91, 133 and 138 MOSs and proposed changes to the NVIS permissions and constraints.

Your feedback will make a valuable contribution to our standards development and making process and help to inform any future regulatory change. 

Documents for review

All documents related to this consultation are attached in the ‘related’ section at the bottom of the page. They are:

  • Summary of proposed change on CD 2109OS, which provides background and additional information on the proposed standards
  • Proposed draft CASR Part 91, 133 and 138 MOS changes
  • Civil Aviation Safety Amendment (Part 91) Regulations 2018 (F2020C00951)
  • Civil Aviation Safety Amendment (Part 133) Regulations 2018 (F2021C00516)
  • Civil Aviation Safety Amendment (Part 138) Regulations 2018 (F2020C00978)
  • Civil Aviation Safety Amendment (Operations Definitions) Regulations 2019 (F2020C00958)
  • Part 91 (General Operating and Flight Rules) Manual of Standards 2020 (F2020L01514)
  • Part 133 (Australian Air Transport Operations—Rotorcraft) Manual of Standards 2020 (F2020L01614)
  • Part 138 (Aerial Work Operations) Manual of Standards 2020 (F2020L01402)
  • Unofficial consolidated CASR Dictionary – (combines the official CASR Dictionary and the official amendment regulation incorporating the operations definitions)
  • MS Word copy of online consultation for ease of distribution and feedback within your organisation. 

Note: The MS Word document is not to be used as an emailed submission, unless there are extenuating circumstances, and this form of submission has been agreed to by the consultation project lead.

CASA highly recommends the use of the ‘unofficial consolidated CASR dictionary’. Some minor differences exist between this document and the ‘Operations Definitions’ regulation however these are isolated to the sport and recreation sectors and do not affect any of the content of this proposed MOS.

Comments on CD 2109OS should be submitted through the online response form.

What happens next

At the end of the response period for public comment, we will review each comment and submission received. We will make all submissions publicly available on the CASA website, unless you request your submission remain confidential. We will also publish a Summary of Consultation which summarises the feedback received, outlines any intended changes and details our plans for the regulation.

All comments on CD 2109OS consultation will be considered. Relevant feedback that improves upon the proposed regulations and is consistent with the regulations and other CASA policy, will be incorporated into the final ruling.

Post-implementation review

CASA will monitor and review the new rules during the transition phase and on an ongoing basis.

Audiences

  • CASA Staff
  • Air operators
  • Airworthiness organisations
  • Flight instructors and flight examiners
  • Flight training operators
  • Engineers
  • Manufacturers
  • Pilots
  • Air traffic controller/s
  • Part 145 of CASR approved maintenance organisations (AMO)
  • Regulation 30 of CAR maintenance organisations (CAR 30)
  • Licensed aircraft maintenance engineers (LAME)
  • Aerial work operator
  • Part 142 of CASR operator
  • Part 141 of CASR operator

Interests

  • Safety management systems
  • Flight training
  • Airworthiness/maintenance (CAR 30 and CASR Part 145 maintenance orgs)
  • In-house training for CASA FOIs